Expensive Academic Conferences – the case of ICDM

I was recently thinking of attending IEEE ICDM 2018 (International Conference on Data Mining) in Singapore, next month. It is a top 5 data mining conference. According to my schedule, I could attend it for 2 days, and since Singapore is close to China, it is convenient to go there. However,  I was quite surprised by how expensive the registration fee of this conference has became. As of today the “standard registration fee (by 28 October)” is roughly 1360 USD$ or 9300 CNY.

icdm registration fee 2018

Registration fees  from ICDM2018 website

This is actually the most expensive conference that I have ever considered attending. Most conferences that I have attended have been in the 300-700 USD range, twice less than ICDM. But is it an outlier? To see more clearly, I decided to compare the standard registration of ICDM 2018 with those of previous editions of ICDM:

  • ICDM 2018: 1360 $ USD (11 % increase from 2017)
  • ICDM 2017: 1220 $ USD  (12% increase from 2015)
  • ICDM 2015: 1080 $USD  (28 % increase from 2013)
  • ICDM 2013: 844 $USD   (68% increase from 2011)
  • ICDM 2011: about 500 $ USD

This is quite interesting. It shows a steady increase in the registration price of the ICDM conference over the years. The registration fee has increased so much, that the price is now 2.7 times higher than 8 years ago!

Why is it so expensive?

One could argue that the reason is the location of the conference. But the increase has been steady over the years no matter where the conference was organized. Moreover, such big conferences have often thousands of attendees, and usually many sponsors. I recently attended the KDD 2018 conference, which was also expensive, but less than ICDM. There was about more than 3000 attendees, and if I remember they received more than 1 million dollars in sponsorship.

Thus, where all this money goes?  A good part goes to renting a convention center, publishing the proceedings and other aspects such as providing scholarships to students. But many conferences also make some considerable profit.  Some conferences are not for profit, while some other conferences will pay the local organizers or the association organizing the conference. I am not sure about how the money is used in the case of ICDM or IEEE and what they will do with the profits, as I could not find the information. But I believe that such big conferences can generate a huge amount of money. By discussing with organizers of smaller conferences (200 attendees) that have much lower registration fees and less sponsorship, I know that some conferences can still make 20,000$ profit.

About IEEE, it is not their only conference in the 1000$ USD range. Some other flagship conferences like IEEE ICC (about communication) also have fees greater than 1000$ USD.  In the field of data mining, the KDD conference is also quite expensive, although currently less than ICDM.  In some ways, many people want to attend these conferences so they are willing to pay these high fees.

Consequences of high registration fees

The consequence of such high registration fees is that some people may not have enough money to attend, and that a lot of money is spent by researchers.  And in many case, that money comes from research projects funded by the government. Thus, one could argue that this money could be used in better ways.

Personally, I was thinking of attending ICDM but when I saw that I would have to pay almost 1400 $ USD for two days to access the conference, I think it is not reasonable to spend that much money. I have enough research funding to pay this but I still do not want to waste the money provided by the government for supporting research. Thus, this year, I will use the money for other things rather than going to ICDM.

Update 2019-03-14: One of the general co-chairs of ICDM 2018 has taken the time to provide his insights and given some explanations about the registration fees of ICDM 2018 in the comment section. You can read the comment. It says that basically, the increase in price would be partially explained by fluctuations of the exchange rate, and the 7% sale tax of Singapore.


Philippe Fournier-Viger is a professor of Computer Science and also the founder of the open-source data mining software SPMF, offering more than 150 data mining algorithms.

(Visited 571 times, 1 visits today)

Comments

Expensive Academic Conferences – the case of ICDM — 7 Comments

  1. An important thing to consider also is that junior professionals / new researchers who may want to hone their skills and experience by attending these conferences might not have the necessary financial ability to do so. If, as you asserted Prof., some of the proceeds generated from these conferences go to scholarships for students. Why not empower students / independent researchers by even giving them a fair enough reasonable discount in conformity with their status and limited experience. Just a thought.

  2. I am also shocked when I see the registration fees of ICDM. With this fact, it’s very hard for young researchers to attend top conferences (but expensive ones) without any funding support, especially those coming from developing countries.

    • Yes, I agree. It is a lot of money. I don’t like this idea of wasting so much money. And, yes, I guess that many people just cannot attend anymore because of the cost. In my opinion the reason is that IEEE may have become too greedy. But the problem is that it is hard to change the publication system.

  3. As the General Co-chair of ICDM 2018, I totally agree with you nowadays the conferences are indeed getting more and more expensive. Saying that, please notice that the registration rates as displayed are in Singapore dollar and include 7% GST (General Service Tax) imposed by Singapore government. ICDM2018 registration rates were set as the same as KDD 2018 rates. Take 890 USD as an example, the Singapore dollar to USD exchange rate was 0.715 back then, so 890 USD = 1245 Singapore dollar, plus the 7% GST, you get 1333 Singapore dollar. Hope that helps.

    • Dear Prof. Zhu, Thanks for taking the time to provide your insights on the price of ICDM 2018. That is very interesting to know how it is calculated. I will update the blog post to mention your insight.

      Best regards,
      Philippe

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *